Edinburgh’s Argyle House moves closer to demolition as deadline set
Edinburgh residents have until December 4 to have their say on proposals to demolish Argyle House, the 1960s concrete office block below Edinburgh Castle that appears in the Netflix drama Dept. Q.
The City of Edinburgh Council advertised two applications covering the site on 13 November. They would replace the building with a mixed-use quarter of homes, hotel accommodation and offices, put forward by development managers Henderson Herd and Mayfly Capital on behalf of owner EIP Jupiter SARL.
The proposal includes 130 homes consisting of 36 studios, 39 one-bedroom, 29 two-bedroom and 26 three-bedroom flats; a 400-room hotel consisting of 244 hotel bedrooms plus 156 aparthotel rooms, with a restaurant and café; as well as about 9,500 square metres of Grade A office space, fronting Castle Terrace.
The developers also promise landscaped gardens, communal courtyards, roof terraces and public spaces. The plans would reopen the historic Baird’s Close as a new route between West Port and King’s Stables Road, and a public lift would link Castle Terrace with King’s Stables Road.
A planning statement prepared by property firm CBRE claims the project would add £145m in gross value added to the city’s economy and support a net 900 jobs. CBRE says the aim is a “high-quality mixed-use development” that sits sympathetically within its sensitive heritage setting.
Plans by Allford Hall Monaghan Morris
The statement argues that refurbishment is not viable. It says the facade has carbonation problems that need ongoing repair, and that the extent of defects in the external wall panels is still to be established. It concedes the building could be retained, but says that would leave a less marketable asset with declining income and rising repair liabilities, and an uncertain future once the current lease ends.
Edinburgh architect Malcolm Fraser, who led a campaign against demolition last year, calls Argyle House “a distinguished modernist building” and says tearing it down would be “madness”. He argues it plays a vital role in the city’s economy, heritage and sustainability.
The Cockburn Association has raised concerns about the environmental cost of removing such a large concrete structure and wants refurbishment and reuse properly considered.
Historic Environment Scotland previously concluded that Argyle House meets the criteria for special architectural or historic interest. It declined to list the building because redevelopment plans were already well advanced.
Public consultation events held earlier this year drew mixed reactions. Some respondents worried about the height and massing of the designs, while others welcomed the green spaces and roof terraces. One argued that terraces cannot replace natural features such as the tree outside the current building.
Argyle House is home to technology firms, including the start-up hub CodeBase, as well as small businesses. It has also become recognisable to international audiences as the headquarters of the fictional police unit in Dept. Q, starring Matthew Goode, and appeared in the TV adaptation of Irvine Welsh’s novel Crime.
Even if councillors approve the applications, demolition is unlikely to begin straight away. The existing headlease runs until 2033, and work is not expected before then.

