Housing associations dispute Dalmarnock Village report, saying it ‘does not reflect the Village as it is today’

Housing associations dispute Dalmarnock Village report, saying it 'does not reflect the Village as it is today'

The three housing associations that manage social rented homes in Glasgow’s Dalmarnock Village have disputed a new report that accuses them of years of systemic failure, saying its findings are historic and based on a small sample of residents.

Published today, A Much Deeper Rot: Housing Conditions in Dalmarnock Village highlights accounts of residents in homes originally built as the Athletes’ Village for Glasgow 2014 who have endured flooding, sewage ingress, collapsing ceilings, damp and mould.

In a statement given exclusively to Scottish Housing News, a spokesperson for Wheatley Homes Glasgow, Thenue Housing Association and West of Scotland Housing Association said there had been issues with some homes in the past, “including problems linked to the original construction”, and apologised to tenants who had had to deal with them.

However, the spokesperson said the report “does not reflect the Village as it is today”, adding that many of its claims date back several years and that the interviews were carried out around a year ago.

Undertaken by Bridgeton Citizens Advice Bureau (BCAB), ‘A Much Deeper Rot’ draws on a survey of 89 households, oral history interviews, photographic evidence and community engagement. 

According to the report:

  • 96.6% of surveyed households had experienced at least one housing problem.
  • 64% reported leaks or flooding and 64% reported poor plumbing.
  • 53.9% reported damp and 50.6% reported mould.
  • 70.8% said housing problems had damaged their overall wellbeing, and 62.9% reported a negative impact on their mental health.
  • 77.8% of surveyed Wheatley Homes Glasgow tenants, 50% of Thenue tenants and 46.7% of West of Scotland Housing Association tenants reported issues lasting more than five years.
  • Only 7.7% of social housing tenants said their issue had been resolved.

Residents quoted in the report describe ceilings collapsing, water “gushing” through ceilings and constant stress. One Wheatley tenant said: “I just feel as if I’m going insane.” A Thenue tenant described buying electric blankets and heaters “just to keep my mother alive”.

Dr James Patrick Ferns, who authored the report, said residents had endured serious defects and repeated failed repairs “while struggling to get the institutions responsible for their homes to take effective action”. He accused institutions of shifting blame onto residents, calling this victim-blaming “reprehensible”.

He also argued that there is a “profound disconnect” between institutional performance reporting and residents’ experiences. He said the regulatory system relies too heavily on evidence generated or commissioned by the organisations being regulated.

Gary Christie, the Poverty Alliance’s policy and campaigns manager, added: “Everyone should be able to live in a safe, secure home. The experiences set out in this report are deeply concerning and show the serious impact that poor housing conditions can have on people’s health, wellbeing and financial security.

“Housing and poverty are inseparable, and no resident should have to spend years living with unresolved problems that undermine their quality of life. Safe, secure housing is a human right and essential to living with dignity.”

Calls for action

Among its recommendations, the report calls on the Scottish Government to:

  • establish an independent Dalmarnock Village Remediation Programme, open to housing association tenants and owner-occupiers, with powers to investigate defects and permanently repair homes
  • provide restitution for residents, including compensation for prolonged disrepair, financial losses, health impacts and distress
  • set up an independent national system for gathering tenants’ experiences, separate from landlords’ own monitoring and reporting directly to the Scottish Housing Regulator
  • explore the “democratisation” of social housing, giving residents meaningful authority over repair and investment decisions

The report welcomes stronger legal protections such as Awaab’s Law, but warns that rights on paper are “meaningless” without enforcement.

Associations’ evidence

In response to the report, the Wheatley Homes Glasgow, Thenue Housing Association and West of Scotland Housing Association pointed out that the homes were built by City Legacy to house athletes for the 2014 Commonwealth Games, not by the housing associations, and did not meet usual specifications or standards, “either then or now”.

They highlight that only 12.7% of the Village’s 700 homes took part in the survey, adding that the eight social landlord homes featured as case studies represent 1.1% of the total and that the interviews were carried out between November 2025 and March 2026.

Between 6 and 12 November, building surveyor specialists inspected 61 Wheatley properties and found only six with “very minor mould”. A further 32 inspections are booked for next week, the association said.

Detailed stock condition surveys have been completed for 84 West of Scotland Housing Association homes over the past nine months, which the association says confirm the homes are in good condition for their age and type.

Thenue said it has current stock condition surveys for 165 homes (82%) in the Village, 26% of them completed in the past eight months. Surveys reviewed so far have identified no major issues, it said.

The associations also say the claims made in the anonymised case studies have not previously been reported to the landlords concerned or raised in meetings with BCAB. They say BCAB has raised only one case with Wheatley since October 2025.

A spokesperson for the housing associations told Scottish Housing News: “There were issues with some homes in the past, including problems linked to the original construction. We’re sorry tenants have had to deal with them.

“But this report does not reflect the Village as it is today. Many of the claims date back several years, and the interviews were carried out around a year ago.

“The report is based on the experiences of a very small number of residents. Our evidence from across the Village shows this is not representative of the wider picture today.

“We are aware of only a small number of outstanding repairs, which are being fixed.

“The three housing associations are working together to complete this work and provide safe, good-quality homes.”

Join over 10,400 housing professionals in receiving our FREE daily email newsletter
Share icon
Share this article: