Landlords have become ‘a convenient punchbag’, survey finds


Scottish Government ministers risk deepening Scotland’s affordable housing problems by unfairly demonising landlords, according to a survey by a rental sector estate agency.

Landlords have become 'a convenient punchbag', survey finds

Chris Wood and Ross MacDonald

Scottish Government ministers risk deepening Scotland’s affordable housing problems by unfairly demonising landlords, according to a survey by a rental sector estate agency.

Portolio is calling on ministers to learn more about who landlords actually are - and the positive difference they make - before imposing new reforms which it believes risk driving increasing numbers out of the business and reducing the number of homes available for rent.

Its co-founders have written to Scotland’s tenants’ rights minister, Patrick Harvie, to highlight their concerns - and the fact that there is no such thing as a typical landlord.

The Edinburgh-based firm’s intervention comes after it conducted a survey of almost 200 rental property owners in Scotland ahead of the publication of a new Private Rented Sector Strategy by the Scottish Government. Portolio’s findings are summarised in the document There’s No Such Thing As A Typical Landlord.

Chris Wood, Portolio co-founder and managing director, said: “Private landlords have become a convenient political punchbag. But the inconvenient truth is that the negative consequences of unfairly demonising landlords far outweigh any positive ones.

“Landlords are sweepingly and unfairly portrayed as fat cat men with bulging property portfolios, exploiting people for profit. The truth could not be further removed for the majority. They simply want to see a fair return for providing quality, safe, affordable homes. Many go above and beyond to support their tenants.

“It’s time that the Scottish Government recognised that a significant proportion of landlords are regular people, from firefighters to teachers, hairdressers to call centre workers. They meet vital needs for affordable homes in their communities but increasingly fear they are being driven out of the business by the hostile attitude towards them. No-one benefits from that. We must work together.”

Portolio is the only estate agency in Scotland which specialises in buying and selling rental properties while tenants remain in their homes, avoiding upheaval for residents while securing unbroken rental income for landlords.

The firm’s recent survey of landlords found that:

  • Nearly seven in 10 landlords never increase the rent of a sitting tenant
  • Only 0.5% of landlords - that’s one in 200 - have never carried out maintenance or repairs to their property
  • 60% of landlords questioned said their tenants had been in place for two years or more
  • The annual buy-to-let profit for landlords with just one property is £4,265
  • Two-thirds of those who responded were aged 35 to 54, with more than a third of landlords women.

Landlords told Portolio:

  • “It feels like the Scottish Government is actively working against landlords.”
  • “The Government’s aim to drive out small investors is evident. This is my pension fund.”
    “I am concerned about the continual trend towards tenants’ rights to the detriment of landlords who are honest, hardworking and diligent in trying to provide good homes
  • for those that need them.”

Portolio co-founder and director of sales, Ross MacDonald, added: “In its manifesto, the SNP stressed that Scotland needs a rented housing sector which offers a range of high-quality and affordable homes for those who choose to live in it. The private sector - and the people within it - helps achieve exactly that. What would happen if private landlords sell up? Who would fill the gap?

“We agree that there needs to be regulation which ensures safety and good living standards. The good, fair people who make up the majority of landlords are committed to providing that. The unhelpful rhetoric and unnecessary regulation which risks driving them out of the business not only threatens supply, but could also see rents rise because of the increasing demand.

“If we ended up with fewer properties for rent, that would not achieve the Scottish Government’s aims. New-build social housing is only one element of addressing affordable housing shortages. Private landlords are part of the solution.”

Share icon
Share this article: